RSS
Print This Post Print This Post

Larry Katzen – Perspectives – REAL Business

Larry Katzen

A Business World Massacre –

What Can Happen When Government Needs A Scapegoat

By Larry Katzen

It remains one of the greatest travesties in the history of American business: In 2001, the 85,000 employees of one of the world’s largest accounting firms began losing their jobs in droves. Their employer had become tainted by its loose association with Enron Corp., a financial house of cards that was imploding and taking with it billions of dollars in employee pensions and shareholder investments.

In 2002, accounting firm Arthur Andersen was convicted of charges related to Enron’s fraudulent practices. The charges had nothing to do with the quality of their auditing – or any of Enron’s illicit practices. The conviction was appealed, and in 2005, the U.S. Supreme Court struck it down in a unanimous vote.

But the damage had already been done.

To date, despite millions of records being subpoenaed, there is no evidence Arthur Andersen ever did anything wrong. Still, perceptions are everything: Most people are not aware that the accounting firm, which led the industry in establishing strict, high standards, became a government scapegoat.

When I speak to groups across the country, I ask the following questions. Below are the typical responses I receive – and the actual facts.

1. What do you remember about Arthur Andersen?
Typical Response: They were the ones that helped facilitate the Enron fraud. They deserved what they got.
Fact: Arthur Andersen was the largest and most prestigious firm in the country. It was considered the gold standard of the accounting profession by the business community.

2. For what was Arthur Andersen indicted?
Typical Response: They messed up the audit of Enron and signed off on false financial statements.
Fact: They were indicted for shredding documents. These documents were drafts and other items that do not support the final product. All accounting firms establish policies for routinely shredding such documents.

3. How long was it between the Enron blowup and when Arthur Andersen went out of business?
Typical Response: One to three years.
Fact: The largest accounting firm in the world was gone in 90 days.

4. Was the indictment upheld?
Typical Response: Yes, that is why they went out of business.
Fact: No. The Supreme Court overruled the lower court in a 9-0 decision, and came to the conclusion within weeks, making it one of their quickest decisions ever.

5. How many people lost their jobs as a result of the false accusations?
Typical Response: Have no idea, but the partners got what they deserved.
Fact: Eighty-five thousand people lost their jobs and only a few thousand were partners. Most were staff people and clericals who made modest sums of money.

6. Who benefited from Arthur Andersen going out of business?
Typical Response: Everyone – we finally got rid of those crooks and made a statement to the rest of business to operate ethically.
Facts: It was not the Arthur Andersen people; they lost their jobs. It was not the clients; they had to go through the stress and expense of finding a new auditing firm. It was not the business world in general: It now has fewer firms from which to choose and rates increased. It was their competitors who benefited– they got Andersen’s best people and clients and were able to increase their rates and profitability.

7. What accounting firms now have ex Arthur Andersen partners playing leadership roles in their firms?
Typical Response: None
Facts: The “big four,” all the large middle-tier firms and many small firms have former Arthur Andersen partners in leadership positions. Finally, many members of the new Public Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), which oversees these firms, now have former Arthur Andersen people involved in reviewing the quality of these firms.

Larry KatzenLarry Katzen, author of “And You Thought Accountants were Boring – My Life Inside Arthur Andersen,” (www.LarryRKatzen.com), worked at Arthur Andersen from 1967 to 2002, quickly rising through the ranks to become a partner at age 30. His new memoir details the government’s unjust persecution of a company known for maintaining the highest standards.

Copyright © 2017 REAL Exclusive Magazine www.getrealexclusive.com
Links to this article are encouraged

Share

Tags:

Leave a Reply


Featured Properties

Ads

REAL HAPPENINGS

Ready...Set...SAVINGS!

Ready...Set...SAVINGS!

Van Wezel Offers Daily Show Discounts Till Christmas. Van Wezel is running a sale a day on 12 di[...]
December 13, 2018 Deck The Halls

December 13, 2018 Deck The Halls

Enjoy A Self Guided Tour Of Ca’ d’Zan. All decked out for the Holidays, Ca’ d’Zan will be open d[...]
Pantone Announces Color Of The Year

Pantone Announces Color Of The Year

Living Coral Is It For 2019. The official selection for the coming year is Living Coral, or spec[...]
December 7, 1941 Day Of Infamy

December 7, 1941 Day Of Infamy

Remember Pearl Harbor. The Day of Infamy that launched the epic conflict with Japan took place a[...]
Tow To Go Celebrates 20 Years

Tow To Go Celebrates 20 Years

Every 49 Minutes A Drunk Driver Kills Someone In The U.S. In 1998, John Saputo - CEO and Preside[...]
December 14, 2018 Jazz At Two

December 14, 2018 Jazz At Two

Sarasota Jazz Project Performs. Join the Jazz Club of Sarasota as they present Jazz at Two at Un[...]
December 6, 2018 Mellon Grant Arts Events

December 6, 2018 Mellon Grant Arts Events

New College Announces December Mellon Grant Arts Events. Dance, music, choreography, Asian film[...]
2018 Sarasota Powerboat Grand Prix Festival OFFICIAL Wrap Up

2018 Sarasota Powerboat Grand Prix Festival OFFICIAL Wrap Up

Suncoast Charities For Children Thanks Sarasota Board Of County Commissioners. Suncoast Charitie[...]
December 7, 2018 Jazz At Two

December 7, 2018 Jazz At Two

Greg Nielsen and Friends Performs. Join the Jazz Club of Sarasota as they present Jazz at Two at[...]
November 22, 2018 Some Thanksgiving Fun

November 22, 2018 Some Thanksgiving Fun

The Directions Say To Have The Bird Chill In The Sink For A Few Hours... Happy Thanksgiving[...]
November 22, 2018 Happy Thanksgiving

November 22, 2018 Happy Thanksgiving

Gather With Friends And Loved Ones To Give Thanks For Life's Blessings. The Pilgrims made seven [...]
November 30, 2018 Jazz At Two

November 30, 2018 Jazz At Two

Skip Conkling and Dixie Mix Performs. Join the Jazz Club of Sarasota as they present Jazz at Two[...]
November 23, 2018 Jazz At Two

November 23, 2018 Jazz At Two

Billy Marcus Trio Performs. Join the Jazz Club of Sarasota as they present Jazz at Two at Unitar[...]
November 19, 2018 Ringling By the Bay

November 19, 2018 Ringling By the Bay

Ringling By the Bay Features Kettle Of Fish. Join The Ringling at Bolger Campiello on Sarasota [...]
November 11, 2018 Veterans Day

November 11, 2018 Veterans Day

Tomb Of The Unknowns And Veterans Day. Official, national ceremonies for Veterans Day center aro[...]
243rd Anniversary Of The United States Marines

243rd Anniversary Of The United States Marines

All Men Are Created Equal Then Some Become Marines. The official birthday of the United States M[...]
November 16, 2018 Jazz At Two

November 16, 2018 Jazz At Two

Valerie Gillespie Ensemble Performs. Join the Jazz Club of Sarasota as they present Jazz at Two [...]
Third Annual Women’s Sports Museum Gala

Third Annual Women’s Sports Museum Gala

Gala Hits A Homerun For Women’s Sports Museum. More than 200 guests attended the 3rd Annual Wom[...]
November 9, 2018 City Of North Port Real Estate Summit

November 9, 2018 City Of North Port Real Estate Summit

The City Of North Port Hosts Third Annual Real Estate Summit. On Friday, November 9, 2018, from [...]
November 30, 2018 Active Shooter Presentation

November 30, 2018 Active Shooter Presentation

Skills To Enhance Your Survival In An Active Shooter Incident. The Manatee Sheriff's Office is o[...]
Translate »